
To be honest, when I first read the assignment my mind went completely blank. I really wasnt sure what my preception of the Vietnam War was; it was always one of those iffy subjects that history teachers tried to skip over or avoid. But I think this perception of uncertainty is normal and a trend found in American society about peoples opionions of the war. The question, " How did the U.S. get involved in the war in the first place, and why did we fight that war?' is a question frequently asked, but seldomly answered in a uniform way. Here's a one-sentence characterization of the relationship between the United States and Vietnam. It was made by President John F. Kennedy in 1962, after the U.S. had already sent some troops to Vietnam, but before full-blown war:
"...As you know, the U.S. for more than a decade has been assisting the government, the people of Vietnam, to maintain their independence."
This statement is misleading. He fails to mention which government we have been supporting, during the Vietnam War era, there was more than one government struggling for control (and the one that had the strongest support among the Vietnamese people wasn't the one the United States was supporting). This is where it becomes clear of why there is so much confussion revolving around the war. Nobody really knew which side was the enemy. I feel that the depiciton engraved into Americans about the war was greatly influenced by media control. We know what the media wanted us to know, and the problem with this is that information can be miscontrued and stretched to the point where it is no longer fact and therefor becomes misleading. I think Tim O' Brian illustrates this uncertainty very well:
"I was drafted to fight a war I hated...Certain blood was being shed for uncertain reasons...The very facts were shrouded in uncertainty...Was it a Civil War? A war of national libertation or simple agression? Who started it, and when, and why?" (The things they carried pg 40)
This Quote sums up my view of the war. Im really not sure what to think about it because there is just so much uncertainty revolving around it and so much that we dont know. I found this video that represents the how the media shaped our views and led us to believe what they wanted us to believe. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XqayiS3NnuY ( I couldnt get the video to upload?!)
3 comments:
I agree with your comments. I went to a public school, which are always kind of hesitant in portraying the truth of many situations like the vietnam war. We grew up thinking that the United States was ethical and the defender of what is just and true, but there are many situations were what is true is blurred by other motivations. This was the time that during the McCarthy trials, where pretty much every prominent leader stood trial for being a communist. Is communism bad? it is just a way to run a country. The idea of communism is considered to be an utopia, where everyone gets equal treatment.
During this era, I keep thinking about the movie Breach, where it depicts the biggest FBI leak in the history of the US. The trader keeps saying that the United States is a baby with a big gun. If we can not understand something then we must destroy it. In Vietnam, the U.S. had a basic idea that they did not want communism to spread so we must send all of are boys to war to defend a country, we really did not have any ties. During this time, the United States did not even declare war upon anyone, Why not if we are going to send so many troops over there, it is due to the fact that no body had any idea of what was going on. Many Americans probably could not point out Vietnam on a map, let alone understand the point of defending the country.
I completely agree with that nobody understands why we were over there or even what was the point for fighting for 11 years.
I am glad that you mentioned the draft. I spoke a great deal about pride in my post. But my family all chose to join and fight. I can't imagine fighting a war you didn't believe in by force. Especially such a controversial war. I know that we can not fight a war without soldiers but the point of war is freedom, and forcing men to fight certainly is not what I would call freedom.
I also find it very sad that this subject is not taught in school. I remember studying WWI and WWII, actually devoting weeks on end to them. I don't understand why discussing one of this counrties most controversial times is inappropriate. I feel that though awful things happend for reasons nobody knows we can still learn from what happened then.
Yes that's a good point about the draft and I didn't think about it until reading your post and these comments. It would be hard to want to fight and do the right thing if you were forced to; I find that similar with school :) Yet at the same time I think if the draft was necessary for our freedom and the soldiers realized that then it wouldn't be a problem.
Post a Comment